AMZN vs MCD
Amazon.com Inc. Common Stock vs McDonald's Corporation Common Stock. Side-by-side ACCE scores, valuation, profitability, and growth.
$AMZN vs $MCD — ACCE Verdict
$AMZN wins on growth and quality; $MCD wins on valuation and income.
$AMZN carries an ACCE score of 64/100 versus $MCD's 48/100, driven by a Growth score of 88 and Quality score of 80. Those aren't decorative — earnings grew 74.8% YoY and ROE sits at 24.3%. The analyst consensus target of $312.99 implies meaningful upside from the current $230.92. The catch: ACCE's 6-model fair value pegs $AMZN at $131.92, a -42.9% gap to current price, and a Value score of just 41 confirms the stock is pricing in a lot of execution.
$MCD trades closer to intrinsic value — the 6-model fair value of $261.99 is only -2.0% below the current $267.46 — and its forward P/E of 20.4 is materially cheaper than $AMZN's 31.2. A 31.6% net margin and 3.7% FCF yield add ballast, and the 2.7% dividend provides real income. But earnings grew just 6.9% YoY, the Momentum score is a weak 25, and the 1Y return is -6.4%.
For growth-oriented portfolios, $AMZN's fundamentals justify the premium. For value and income, $MCD is the steadier bet — just don't expect near-term price momentum.