Freeport-McMoRan's ($FCX) ACCE composite score dropped 11 points, moving from 72 to 61. That's a meaningful single-step decline — large enough to shift how the stock sits relative to peers in the Basic Materials sector and worth unpacking.
The current subscore breakdown reads: Growth 35, Value 60, Quality 72, Momentum 77 — each out of 100. That Growth score of 35 stands out immediately. It's the weakest of the four pillars by a wide margin, and it's the most likely driver of a composite move this size.
What it means
Growth is the weak link. A Growth score of 35 signals that the model sees limited near-term expansion in the business. The live data backs that up: year-over-year revenue is down 7.3%. Earnings grew 27.1% over the same period, which is a positive, but revenue contraction tends to weigh heavily on growth-oriented scoring because it raises questions about whether earnings improvement is structural or the result of cost-cutting and margin management rather than top-line momentum.
Get the ACCE weekly digest
Index returns, picks recap, score movers - every Sunday. No fluff.
Valuation is a real concern. The Value score sits at 60 — middling — and the 6-model fair value estimate of $41.54 is 31.4% below the current price of $60.52. That gap is substantial. A trailing P/E of 29.4 and a forward P/E of 22.1 suggest the market is pricing in a meaningful earnings recovery, but the composite valuation model isn't confirming that optimism. When price runs well ahead of modeled fair value, Value subscores tend to compress, which can pull the composite down even when other factors hold steady.
Quality and Momentum are holding up. Quality at 72 reflects genuinely solid fundamentals: ROE of 14.8%, a net margin of 11.4%, and earnings quality flagged as strong. Momentum at 77 is consistent with $FCX's 1-year return of 40.0% — the stock has had a strong run. These two subscores are likely what kept the composite from falling further.
The tension in the story. $FCX is a stock where the recent price performance (strong) and the underlying valuation signal (stretched) are pulling in opposite directions. Analyst consensus targets $71.73, above the current $60.52, but the ACCE fair-value model sits well below both. That divergence between analyst targets and model-based fair value is worth watching. Score moves like this one often reflect the model recalibrating as price appreciation outpaces fundamental improvement.
The 11-point drop doesn't mean $FCX has become a broken business — Quality and Momentum scores don't fall apart overnight. But the Growth score of 35 and the valuation gap are clear signals that the composite is flagging risk at the current price level.
For the live score and full breakdown, visit acceinvestments.com/stocks/FCX.
ACCE scores thousands of stocks across valuation models matched to each company, with fair value, conviction and the full thesis on every name. Start free, no card required.
