The ACCE composite score for $ICE (Intercontinental Exchange) dropped 10 points, moving from 64 to 54 out of 100. That's a meaningful single-step decline, and the current subscore breakdown tells a clear story about where the pressure is coming from.
The four subscores as of now: Growth 48, Value 60, Quality 86, Momentum 23.
Momentum at 23 is the obvious weak point. $ICE has returned -21.2% over the past year, and that kind of price performance feeds directly into momentum-based signals. A score in the low 20s suggests the stock has been trending in the wrong direction for long enough that quantitative momentum models are flagging it as a laggard. If momentum was previously a stronger contributor to the composite, a further deterioration there alone could account for a 10-point composite swing.
Recevez le résumé hebdomadaire ACCE
Performance des indices, bilan des sélections, plus fortes variations de score : chaque dimanche, sans superflu.
Growth at 48 sits just below the midpoint. Year-over-year revenue grew 4.8% and earnings grew 14.2%, which are decent numbers in isolation, but growth subscores also incorporate forward-looking signals — analyst estimate revisions, expected revenue acceleration, and earnings trajectory. If forward estimates softened or the rate of estimate revisions turned negative, the growth subscore could have pulled the composite lower even with solid trailing figures.
Value at 60 is the second-strongest subscore. The trailing P/E sits at 21.4 and the forward P/E at 23.4, which is a slightly unusual inversion — the forward multiple is higher than the trailing one, implying the market expects near-term earnings to come in below recent levels. The 6-model fair value estimate of $141.50 actually sits 4.7% below the current price of $148.54, which means the quantitative valuation models see the stock as modestly overvalued at current levels. That limits how much the value subscore can support the composite.
Quality at 86 remains the standout. A net margin of 38.3%, ROE of 14.1%, and FCF yield of 5.0% are genuinely strong figures. The earnings quality flag is listed as mixed, which is worth watching, but the core profitability metrics keep the quality subscore well above average.
What it means
A 10-point composite drop of this kind typically reflects a combination of momentum deterioration and a softening in either growth or valuation signals — not a collapse in business fundamentals. $ICE's quality metrics remain among the stronger readings in the Financial Services coverage universe.
The analyst consensus target of $182.23 implies significant upside from the current price of $148.54, but the ACCE model's own fair value estimate of $141.50 tells a more cautious story. Those two signals are pointing in opposite directions, which is part of why the composite sits in the mid-50s rather than higher.
For the full live score breakdown and updated fair value, see the $ICE stock page at acceinvestments.com/stocks/ICE.
ACCE scores thousands of stocks across valuation models matched to each company, with fair value, conviction and the full thesis on every name. Start free, no card required.
