$TM just recorded a 10-point drop in its ACCE composite score, moving from 63 to 53 out of 100. That is a meaningful single-step decline, and it warrants a closer look at where the pressure is coming from.
The current score breakdown reads: Growth 47, Value 95, Quality 46, Momentum 25. A composite score of 53 reflects a stock that scores exceptionally well on one dimension — value — while lagging on almost everything else. The Momentum subscore of 25 stands out immediately as the likely anchor dragging the composite lower.
What it means
Momentum (25/100) is the most probable driver of a drop this size. Momentum subscores respond to price action and relative performance trends. $TM has posted a 1-year return of -2.2% at a current price of $171.89, underperforming in a period when many equity benchmarks moved higher. When a stock trails its peers over a rolling window, momentum models reprice quickly and sharply — a 10-point composite swing is consistent with that kind of deterioration.
Recibe el resumen semanal de ACCE
Rentabilidad de los índices, repaso de las selecciones y los mayores cambios de puntuación, cada domingo. Sin relleno.
Growth (47/100) sits just below the midpoint. Year-over-year revenue grew 1.9%, which is modest for a consumer cyclical. Earnings growth came in at 23.2% year-over-year, which is a strong number on its own, but growth subscores also factor in forward estimates and trend consistency. If forward guidance softened or analyst estimate revisions turned negative, the growth subscore could have contributed to the composite decline even without a dramatic headline miss.
Quality (46/100) is also below the midpoint despite some genuinely solid underlying metrics. ROE sits at 10.2% and net margin at 7.6%. The FCF yield of 291.6% is a striking figure and is flagged as strong earnings quality — so the quality subscore weakness likely reflects something structural, such as balance sheet leverage, asset turnover, or consistency of returns relative to the auto sector peer group, rather than a cash flow problem.
Value (95/100) remains the standout. A trailing P/E of 9.4 and a forward P/E of 10.4 are low multiples for a company of this scale. The six-model fair value estimate sits at $209.14, implying 21.7% upside from the current price of $171.89. The analyst consensus target of $256.52 points even higher. On pure valuation, $TM looks cheap. The problem is that cheap stocks can stay cheap — or get cheaper — when momentum is weak and growth is uninspiring.
The 3.6% dividend yield provides some return while investors wait, but a score of 53 signals that the composite picture has deteriorated. Value alone is not enough to carry the overall rating when growth, quality, and momentum are all pulling in the other direction.
For the full live scorecard, visit acceinvestments.com/stocks/TM.
ACCE scores thousands of stocks across valuation models matched to each company, with fair value, conviction and the full thesis on every name. Start free, no card required.
