Casey's General Stores ($CASY) reported results for its most recent quarter (reported June 9, 2026), and the headline earnings number stands out sharply. EPS came in at $0.00, compared to $2.63 in the same period a year earlier — a year-over-year decline of exactly 100.0%.
Revenue told a different story, though not a dramatic one. The top line grew 0.3% year over year, meaning the business kept sales roughly flat while earnings collapsed entirely. That gap between a stable revenue line and a zeroed-out EPS figure points to significant cost pressure, one-time charges, or both hitting the bottom line during the period. We don't have guidance commentary from management to clarify which factors drove the disconnect or what the company expects going forward.
What it means
At a current price of $754.29 and a market cap of $28.24B, $CASY carries a trailing P/E of 43.7. With EPS at $0.00 for the most recent quarter, that trailing multiple is now stretched in a way that makes the forward P/E of 38.3 the more relevant valuation anchor — it implies analysts expect earnings to recover meaningfully from this quarter's result.
Recibe el resumen semanal de ACCE
Rentabilidad de los índices, repaso de las selecciones y los mayores cambios de puntuación, cada domingo. Sin relleno.
The analyst consensus target sits at $842.81, which represents upside from the current price. Whether that target holds after this earnings print will depend on how the Street interprets the cause of the EPS wipeout.
The dividend yield is 0.3%, a modest income component that does little to cushion the valuation conversation at current levels.
$CASY's ACCE score currently sits at 60 out of 100 — a middling read that reflects the mixed picture here. Revenue stability in a convenience-store and fuel retail model is not nothing; Casey's runs a large store network with consistent customer traffic. But a 100% year-over-year EPS decline demands explanation, and without guidance commentary, the picture stays incomplete for now.
Traders and long-term holders alike will want to watch for any management commentary or filings that shed light on what drove earnings to zero this quarter. Until that clarity arrives, the fundamentals as reported leave more questions than answers.
ACCE scores thousands of stocks across valuation models matched to each company, with fair value, conviction and the full thesis on every name. Start free, no card required.
