MCD vs TSLA
McDonald's Corporation Common Stock vs Tesla Inc. Common Stock. Side-by-side ACCE scores, valuation, profitability, and growth.
$MCD wins this comparison, and it's not particularly close.
The valuation gap is extreme. $TSLA trades at a trailing P/E of 329.0 and a forward P/E of 181.8, while $MCD sits at 21.5 trailing and 20.1 forward. ACCE's 6-model fair value puts $TSLA at $24.74, implying -92.9% downside from its current $348.75. $MCD's fair value of $160.38 suggests it is also overpriced at $265.00, but the degree of overvaluation is incomparable.
Profitability tells the same story. $MCD posts a net margin of 31.7% and FCF yield of 3.8%. $TSLA's net margin is 3.7% with FCF yield of just 0.5%. Revenue growth at $TSLA is stronger (25.5% vs 3.7%), but earnings are actually down 3.0% year-over-year, which makes the 329x earnings multiple harder to justify.
$MCD also pays a 2.8% dividend and carries a Quality score of 58 vs $TSLA's 42. The ACCE composite reflects this: $MCD scores 43/100 against $TSLA's 34/100.
$TSLA is a growth story priced for perfection with deteriorating earnings. $MCD is a high-margin, cash-generating business trading at a reasonable multiple with analyst upside to $315.39.