Toyota Motor Corporation's ($TM) ACCE composite score moved from 52 to 63, a delta of +11 points. That's a meaningful single-step move for a large-cap stock — the kind that typically reflects a shift in at least one of the three underlying subscore pillars: Growth, Value, or Quality.
The current breakdown reads Growth 47, Value 95, Quality 46 — all out of 100.
The Value subscore at 95 is the standout. $TM trades at a trailing P/E of 9.5 and a forward P/E of 10.4, both low relative to most Consumer Cyclical peers. The six-model fair-value estimate sits at $371.26, which represents a 113.4% premium to the current price of $173.94. The analyst consensus target of $256.52 points in the same direction, though it implies a more conservative upside. A score jump of this size often traces back to the Value pillar tightening further — either because the price softened, earnings estimates moved up, or both.
Get the ACCE weekly digest
Index returns, picks recap, score movers - every Sunday. No fluff.
What it means
The most concrete catalyst visible in the data is earnings momentum. Year-over-year earnings growth came in at +23.2% against revenue growth of just +1.9%. That gap — strong earnings expansion on modest top-line growth — points to margin improvement or cost discipline, and it's the kind of signal that can lift a composite score even when the Growth subscore (currently 47) stays moderate. Revenue growth near 2% keeps the Growth pillar from scoring higher, which is why the composite lands at 63 rather than pushing into the 70s or 80s.
The Quality subscore at 46 is the other soft spot. $TM's ROE is 10.2% and net margin is 7.6% — respectable for an automaker, but not exceptional by cross-sector standards. The FCF yield, however, is 287.5%, and earnings quality is flagged as strong. That FCF figure is striking and suggests the business generates substantial cash relative to its market cap of $205.96B. If the Quality subscore was dragged lower by return metrics while FCF strength was underweighted, there's a case that the score could continue moving as models recalibrate.
The dividend yield of 3.6% adds a tangible return component while investors wait for any price rerating.
A score of 63 is a constructive signal, not a euphoric one. The Value pillar is doing heavy lifting, Growth is middling, and Quality sits below the midpoint. The score move from 52 to 63 likely reflects the earnings growth data landing in the model alongside the persistent gap between price and fair value. Whether the score holds or climbs further depends on whether the next earnings cycle sustains that earnings-growth-to-revenue-growth spread.
For current price and live score updates, see acceinvestments.com/stocks/TM.
See the full picture, free
ACCE scores thousands of stocks across six valuation models, with fair value, conviction and the full thesis on every name. Start free, no card required.
